Essential Recordings
Where to Start Listening
For a definitive saxophone-led jazz treatment, seek out Stan Getz and the Oscar Peterson Trio, recorded 10 October 1957 in Los Angeles for Verve. The album opens with a bop-inflected reading of I Want to Be Happy, Getz's tenor gliding over the tune's turnaround with the light, relaxed swing that defines the session — a pianoless-adjacent setting with Peterson, guitarist Herb Ellis and bassist Ray Brown giving Getz plenty of open space.
The tune's earliest recordings came from dance bands including Vincent Lopez and Jan Garber in the mid-1920s, and it went on to be recorded by big bands including Benny Goodman. Comparing an early dance-band reading against Getz's 1957 bebop-era treatment is a good way to hear how far the tune travelled.
The tune's first vocal hits, by dance bands including Vincent Lopez and Jan Garber in the mid-1920s, and later big-band versions by Benny Goodman, established it as a standard well before its jazz-improvisation life took hold. Comparing an early dance-band reading against Rollins's bebop treatment is a good way to hear how far the tune travelled.
If you are working through the broader Great American Songbook repertoire, browse the online real book index for related tunes, all available as free lead sheet PDFs in Concert, Bb and Eb. If you are also studying Tea for Two, both tunes are connected to the same 1925 production of No, No, Nanette, making them an interesting pair to study together.
Want the full, official Youmans score — including the piano arrangement and Irving Caesar's lyrics? A licensed songbook is a worthwhile addition to any player's shelf alongside this free chart.
We may earn a small commission on purchases made through affiliate links, at no extra cost to you.