Essential Recordings
Where to Start Listening
For a purely instrumental take, seek out Artie Shaw and his small-group unit, the Gramercy Five, who recorded this tune with Shaw's clarinet leading a compact swing combo. It is a good demonstration of how the tune plays as a pure melodic vehicle once the vocal is set aside.
On the vocal side, Lee Wiley's 1939 recording is the version that reinvented this tune as a ballad and permanently changed how it is understood. Frank Sinatra's November 1947 recording, with Bobby Hackett on trumpet, is essential listening for how a great vocalist shapes the melody’s short, songful phrases — he returned to the tune again in 1960 for his album Nice ‘n’ Easy.
Ella Fitzgerald's version from her 1959 Gershwin Song Book, arranged by Nelson Riddle, is a benchmark reading and contributed to the album’s Grammy win the following year. Comparing all three recordings side by side is one of the best ways to hear how much interpretive freedom a simple, well-built melody can support.
If you are working through the broader Great American Songbook repertoire, browse the online real book index for related tunes, all available as free lead sheet PDFs in Concert, Bb and Eb. If you are also studying I Got Rhythm, comparing Gershwin’s uptempo writing against this tune’s ballad afterlife is a good way to hear the range of his work.
Want the full, official Gershwin score — including the piano arrangement and Ira Gershwin’s lyrics? A licensed Gershwin songbook is a worthwhile addition to any player’s shelf alongside this free chart.
We may earn a small commission on purchases made through affiliate links, at no extra cost to you.