Essential Recordings
Where to Start Listening
For a woodwind-led instrumental jazz treatment, seek out Benny Goodman and His Orchestra's recording from 5 November 1936, released on Victor 25497, where Goodman's clarinet carries the melody through the tune's chromatic movement with characteristic swing-era clarity.
The tune's earliest recording of note came from Paul Whiteman and His Orchestra in 1924, released as Victor 19414, which helped establish it as a top-ten hit within months of its Broadway introduction.
The tune has gone on to be recorded by singers including Peggy Lee, Ella Fitzgerald, Dinah Shore and more than 300 other artists, alongside instrumentalists such as Lionel Hampton and Oscar Peterson. Comparing an early dance-band reading against a later small-group jazz version is a good way to hear how far the tune has travelled.
If you are working through the broader Great American Songbook repertoire, browse the online real book index for related tunes, all available as free lead sheet PDFs in Concert, Bb and Eb. If you are also studying other early Gershwin standards, The Man I Love is a useful point of comparison — written just a few years later, once Gershwin's writing partnership with his brother Ira was fully established.
Want the full, official Gershwin score — including the piano arrangement and Ballard MacDonald and Buddy DeSylva's lyrics? A licensed Gershwin songbook is a worthwhile addition to any player's shelf alongside this free chart.
We may earn a small commission on purchases made through affiliate links, at no extra cost to you.